
Anggota Komisi II DPR RI Ahmad Irawan.|Foto: Naefuroji/jk
PARLEMENTARIA, Jakarta — Ahmad Irawan, a member of Commission II of the House of Representatives of the Republic of Indonesia, said the sanctions set out in the Draft Law on Population Administration (Adminduk) should draw a clear line between administrative violations and criminal offenses. Enforcement of population administration rules should prioritize administrative remedies as long as a violation can still be corrected without resorting to criminal proceedings.
He said that in drafting the regulation, lawmakers should strike a balance between legal certainty and proportionate sanctions. Not every error or violation in the administration of population records should result in criminal penalties, particularly when the matter can still be resolved through administrative correction mechanisms.
"There needs to be a clear distinction between conduct classified as an administrative violation and conduct that may be classified as a criminal offense. We must not allow every administrative issue to be dealt with through a criminal-law approach," Irawan said at a meeting of the Adminduk Bill working committee of Commission II, held at the Nusantara Building, House of Representatives, Senayan, Jakarta, on Wednesday (18/11/2026).
He added that the provisions should also take into account the nature of the violation and the degree of fault of the parties involved. Correctable administrative errors should be distinguished from acts involving intent, abuse of authority, or other conduct that causes serious harm to the public.
He said lessons from how population administration is managed in other countries could also inform the drafting of the sanctions provisions. However, their application should be adapted to the characteristics of Indonesia's legal system and the needs of governance in the country.
Through deliberations on the Adminduk Bill, the Golkar Party faction legislator also expressed hope that the sanctions provisions would provide legal certainty while ensuring justice for the public. Proportionate rules are needed to ensure that population administration enforcement does not burden citizens, while still deterring abuse and violations that harm the public interest.
"We must not criminalize issues that can actually still be resolved administratively. At the same time, conduct involving serious violations must carry clear legal consequences," he concluded. (ujm/rdn)