
Anggota Komisi III DPR RI Nasir Djamil saat Keynote Speech dalam Diskusi Terpumpun dengan tema "Analisis Batas Konstitusional Open Legal Policy Dan Penggunaannya Dalam Penyusunan Keterangan DPR" di Universitas Trisakti.|Foto: Septamares/jk
PARLEMENTARIA, Jakarta – The authority of lawmakers to determine policy does not mean they have unlimited freedom. Every regulation enacted by the House of Representatives (DPR) together with the government must remain grounded in the Constitution and take citizens’ rights into account. This was stressed by Nasir Djamil, a member of Commission III of the Indonesian House of Representatives, while discussing the concept of Open Legal Policy at a discussion forum at Trisakti University in Jakarta on Monday (16/11/2026).
In his keynote address at a Focus Group Discussion titled “Analysis of the Constitutional Limits of Open Legal Policy and Its Use in Drafting the DPR’s Statements,” Nasir explained that open legal policy is the scope granted by the Constitution to lawmakers to determine various provisions not set out in detail in the 1945 Constitution.
This scope encompasses a range of decisions, from setting age limits and the severity of criminal penalties to determining time frames and designing institutions. In making these policy decisions, lawmakers may take into account social conditions, budgetary capacity, institutional readiness, and public aspirations.
However, Nasir cautioned that this authority remains subject to constitutional limits. “The freedom to choose a policy is different from freedom from constitutional limits. The scope for choice lies within the Constitution and never above it,” he stressed.
According to the PKS faction politician, the more a statutory provision affects citizens’ constitutional rights, the stronger the justification lawmakers must provide. Technical and administrative regulations generally allow greater policy discretion.
By contrast, rules that restrict freedoms, treat groups in society differently, or curtail citizens’ rights require more thorough consideration. He also noted that restrictions on human rights must comply with Article 28J paragraph (2) of the 1945 Constitution: they must be based on law and serve purposes permitted by the Constitution.
Lessons from Changes to the Minimum Marriage Age
To explain how open legal policy works in practice, Nasir discussed the history of judicial review of the minimum marriage age provision at the Constitutional Court (MK). In 2015, the MK rejected a petition challenging the minimum marriage age provision, considering its determination part of lawmakers’ open legal policy.
However, on December 13, 2018, through Decision No. 22/PUU-XV/2017, the MK ruled that the provision setting the minimum marriage age for women at 16 was contrary to the 1945 Constitution. The MK then ordered lawmakers to amend it within no more than three years.
The DPR and the government subsequently followed up on the ruling through Law No. 16 of 2019 on Amendments to Law No. 1 of 1974 on Marriage. The new law set the same minimum marriage age for men and women at 19.
Nasir said this process shows that recognizing a matter as open legal policy does not automatically rule out the possibility of a provision being challenged again before the MK, particularly if the challenge rests on different grounds or constitutional arguments.
DPR Statements Must Be Backed by Reasons and Data
The PKS Party faction politician further stressed that, when facing a judicial review of a law, it is not enough for the DPR simply to state that a provision is a matter of open legal policy. The DPR’s statement must explain the purpose of the regulation, the reasons for choosing a particular provision, and respond to the constitutional objections raised by the petitioner.
In his view, this explanation should be supported by traceable documents and data, such as the Academic Paper, the Problem Inventory List (DIM), working committee meeting records, working meeting records, and the data used as the basis for deliberating the law.
Nasir therefore underscored the importance of documenting every consideration behind the drafting of a law from the outset of the legislative process. This ensures that, if a provision is challenged later, the DPR has a sound basis for its arguments.
He also stressed that judicial review hearings should not be viewed as a battleground between the DPR and the Constitutional Court. They have different powers, but operate within the same constitutional framework.
The DPR and the President exercise the authority to enact laws, while the MK reviews their conformity with the 1945 Constitution. In this context, the DPR’s statement is an important part of helping judges understand the background and rationale behind a provision.
Accordingly, the legislator for Aceh III urged that the trust the Constitution places in lawmakers be upheld through policies grounded in sound reasoning and open to public scrutiny. “We preserve that trust with reasons that can be traced, tested, and accounted for, both before the Court and before the people,” he concluded. (aas/rdn)