
Anggota Komisi IV DPR Firman Soebagyo.|Foto: Oji/sai
PARLEMENTARIA, Jakarta — House Commission IV member Firman Soebagyo has criticized the government’s plan to relocate part of the Javan rhino population from Ujung Kulon National Park in Banten to Alas Purwo National Park in Banyuwangi, East Java. Firman said the plan must not be rushed and must be backed by comprehensive, transparent scientific studies.
“I support the idea of establishing a second Javan rhino population. It is a conservation necessity. But I strongly criticize the way it is being done and the timing. This must not be rushed. This is not like moving goats; it means moving the rarest animal in the world,” Firman said in a press release to Parlementaria in Senayan, Jakarta, on Tuesday (17/11/2026).
The Golkar Party faction legislator stressed that he supports the government’s efforts to establish a second Javan rhino population as part of a conservation strategy to prevent extinction. However, he warned that relocating the endangered animals carries major risks that must be carefully assessed.
Firman noted that the current Javan rhino population is estimated at only around 80 animals, all of them in Ujung Kulon National Park. This makes it essential to approach any relocation decision with extreme caution, as it concerns the survival of one of the world’s rarest species.
“The Javan rhino does not belong only to Banten or only to East Java. It belongs to Indonesia and to the world. We must not gamble with the 80 animals that remain,” Firman stressed.
Serious Risks
At least five serious risks must be addressed by the government before the Javan rhino translocation plan is carried out. First is the risk of death during the translocation process. The Javan rhino, he said, is highly sensitive to stress. The capture, anesthesia and transport from Banten to Banyuwangi could cause physical strain that may endanger the animals.
Second, Firman explained, is the suitability of the destination habitat. “Does Alas Purwo National Park really have the ecological conditions suited to the Javan rhino’s needs? This includes year-round food availability, water quality, soil characteristics and the presence of wallows that support the animals’ lives,” he said.
According to the Golkar Party faction legislator, habitat suitability cannot be established through preliminary observations alone; it must be demonstrated through scientific studies and long-term monitoring. Third is the risk of disease transmission. Relocated animals could carry diseases from their original habitat to the new location.
Conversely, Javan rhinos could also be exposed to diseases not previously found in Ujung Kulon. Therefore, health screenings, a strict quarantine system and epidemiological studies are needed before any relocation takes place. Fourth is the risk of conflict and poaching. Firman said the readiness of security measures in Alas Purwo must be treated as a serious concern.
“Given the high value of rhino horns on the black market, the government must ensure that these animals are adequately protected, including from illegal poaching and potential conflicts with human activities around the area,” Firman emphasized.
Fifth, Firman continued, is the genetic risk to the population’s long-term survival. He stressed the importance of selecting which individuals to relocate based on their genetic condition and reproductive capacity. The relocation must not reduce the breeding potential of the Ujung Kulon population or create genetic problems in the new population.
In view of these various risks, Firman urged the government to postpone the relocation until all aspects of preparedness have been properly assessed and can be accounted for.
He also called on the government to establish an independent study team comprising rhino experts, veterinarians, geneticists, ecologists and representatives of local communities. The study, he said, must follow International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) standards, be conducted transparently and be made available to the public.
“I urge the government to establish an independent study team made up of rhino experts, veterinarians, geneticists, ecologists and local communities. The study must follow IUCN standards, be transparent and be made public. It must not be a closed-door study intended only to legitimize a project,” Firman concluded. (pun/aha)